Fentanyl Penalties and Overdose Deaths
Overdose deaths in the U.S. have fallen three years in a row, and everybody has a theory about why. In our first episode, Emma and Ezra look at what peer-reviewed research can and can't tell us about one of those theories: criminal penalties for drug possession.
Colorado made possessing small amounts of fentanyl a felony in 2022. Oregon went the other direction in 2021 and decriminalized possessing small amounts of every drug. Two studies, two directions, one narrower question: when a state changes the penalty for possession, do overdose deaths change? Neither study found a detectable change, and both are honest about what they can't show. Along the way: why "no detectable change" isn't the same as "no effect," how researchers build a statistical twin of a state, and three questions worth asking of any proposal.
Colorado voters approved Proposition 132 on November 3, 2026. This episode doesn't tell you how to vote or what policy to adopt; it covers what the research found.
What to take away
- What the studies support: in Colorado and Oregon, changing the penalty for possession didn't detectably change overall overdose deaths (in Oregon, once the drug supply is accounted for).
- What they can't tell us: why deaths are falling nationally. Both studies cover years before the national decline, and neither is an experiment.
- A question for any proposal: compared to what? Is there a comparison group, and does the analysis account for the drug supply?
For practitioners and policymakers
- A law rarely arrives alone. Colorado's law also expanded harm reduction and jail treatment in 2023, so no single piece gets all the credit or all the blame.
- Three questions worth asking of any proposal: Is there a comparison group? Does the analysis account for the drug supply? Will anyone track what happens, such as how often the law is actually charged?
- These studies speak to possession penalties only. They don't test Proposition 132 itself, which goes further than Colorado's 2022 law.
The research
- Jurecka, C., Adams, J., Padmanabhan, P., Glanz, J., Christine, P., Guan, X., Kline, D., Binswanger, I., & Barocas, J. (2025). Implementation of a statewide fentanyl possession law and opioid-related overdose deaths. JAMA Health Forum, 6(8), e252654. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamahealthforum.2025.2654
- Zoorob, M. J., Park, J. N., Kral, A. H., Lambdin, B. H., & del Pozo, B. (2024). Drug decriminalization, fentanyl, and fatal overdoses in Oregon. JAMA Network Open, 7(9), e2431612. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.31612
In the news
- CDC National Center for Health Statistics. U.S. Overdose Deaths Decrease for Third Consecutive Year in 2025. May 13, 2026.
- Fox News. Fentanyl deaths plunge 22% as Trump White House touts crackdown on deadly drug crisis. Aug. 21, 2026. (The White House's claim.)
- WUSF / Florida Phoenix. DeSantis: Tough fentanyl laws have led to 60% dip in drug deaths in three years. Oct. 23, 2026. (The governor's claim.)
- STAT (First Opinion). Overdose deaths have plunged. We need to know why. Oct. 23, 2026. (Opinion.)
- CBS News Colorado. Coverage of the Proposition 132 result. Nov. 6, 2026.
- Colorado Legislative Council. Blue Book: Increase penalties for fentanyl crimes (Proposition 132). 2026.
The fine print
- Neither study is an experiment, so neither proves cause and effect.
- Colorado had no comparison state and no data on how often the new felony was charged.
- Oregon's estimate is imprecise, and its fentanyl measure (from police lab samples) only approximates the street.
- Neither study tests Proposition 132 itself.
Credits
Hosts: Emma Reed and Ezra James (AI-generated voices, made with ElevenLabs). Outro music created with Eleven Music. Website: frompeertoear.com. Contact and corrections: frompeertoear@gmail.com. If we got something wrong, tell us and we'll fix it.
This podcast uses AI-generated host voices. Emma Reed and Ezra James are not real people. The research, scripts, and fact-checking are directed by a human producer.
