Work Requirements in SNAP and Medicaid
Starting January 1, 2027, many adults on expansion Medicaid will have to document work, volunteering, or school to keep their coverage, and the federal rules for SNAP work requirements are being rewritten too. So what did researchers find when work requirements were actually tried? In Episode 2, Emma and Ezra look at two peer-reviewed studies.
The first followed Virginia SNAP participants when the state brought its work rule back in 2013, using a birthday cutoff at age fifty as a natural experiment: many more people left the program, and the study could not detect a gain in employment. The second looked at Georgia, the first state to attach work requirements to a Medicaid expansion: no clear change in coverage or employment against neighboring states, and coverage that lagged South Dakota, which expanded without a requirement. Along the way: why "no detectable gain" isn't "no gain," how turning fifty can work as an experiment, and three neutral questions to ask of any proposal.
This episode doesn't tell you what to think about these rules; it covers what the research found.
What to take away
- What the studies support: in Virginia, the SNAP work rule went with many more people leaving the program, and no detectable employment gain. In Georgia, Medicaid coverage did not clearly change against neighboring states, but lagged a state that expanded without a requirement.
- What they can't tell us: what will happen to any one person, why people left, or how the new rules will play out. Neither study saw individual reasons for leaving.
- A question for any proposal: compared to what? Is there a comparison group, and will anyone measure jobs and coverage, not just enrollment?
For practitioners and policymakers
- If a rule changes, track who drops off and at which step. Neither study could see individual reasons, and that gap is visible from a front desk.
- Three neutral questions for any proposal: Is there a comparison group? Will anyone measure jobs and coverage, not just enrollment? And for how long?
- For the public: if rules change where you live, read your state agency's notices closely. The research doesn't yet say paperwork is the whole story.
The research
- Gray, C., Leive, A., Prager, E., Pukelis, K., & Zaki, M. (2023). Employed in a SNAP? The impact of work requirements on program participation and labor supply. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 15(1), 306–341. https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.20200561 (The full article is behind the publisher's paywall. An earlier working paper is free from NBER: nber.org/papers/w28877.)
- Johnson, D. Y., Mein, S. A., Marinacci, L. X., Liu, M., & Wadhera, R. K. (2025). Insurance coverage and employment after Medicaid expansion with work requirements: Quasi-experimental difference-in-differences study. BMJ, 390, e086792. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj-2025-086792 (Open access.)
In the news
- Courthouse News. Judge blocks Trump administration from enforcing new "medically frail" Medicaid rule. Oct. 29, 2026.
- States Newsroom. Judge strikes down Trump 'medical frailty' rule in Medicaid work requirements. Oct. 29, 2026.
- MPR News. Judge blocks Trump administration's Medicaid rule forcing sick recipients to prove frailty. Oct. 30, 2026.
- CBS Austin / TNND. Federal judge blocks Trump Medicaid work-rule limits on 'medically frail' exemptions. Late Oct. 2026.
- Federal Register (public inspection). Modification to Work Requirements for Able-Bodied Adults (USDA proposed rule, FNA-2025-0368). Filed Nov. 9; scheduled Nov. 10, 2026.
- Stateline. SNAP work requirements don't boost jobs, but drop participation, research finds. Apr. 10, 2026.
- Stateline. Judge rejects states' bid to block Medicaid work rules. Jul. 31, 2026.
The fine print
- The SNAP study is Virginia in the mid-2010s and is strongest for people near age fifty. The Medicaid study is one state, about fifteen months, from a survey with a low response rate.
- Gray's jobs result relies on state unemployment-insurance records, which can miss self-employment and informal work.
- Neither study examined hardship, health, or food security, and neither saw individual reasons for leaving.
- "No clear change" means the margins were wide; it isn't the same as "no change."
- The versions discussed are the peer-reviewed journal articles. The SNAP study first circulated as a working paper.
- Rules are changing quickly. The federal rules described in the episode were current as of Nov. 13, 2026.
Credits
Hosts: Emma Reed and Ezra James (AI-generated voices, made with ElevenLabs). Outro music created with Eleven Music. Website: frompeertoear.com. Contact and corrections: frompeertoear@gmail.com. If we got something wrong, tell us and we'll fix it.
This podcast uses AI-generated host voices. Emma Reed and Ezra James are not real people. The research, scripts, and fact-checking are directed by a human producer.
